Electric vs gas heat gun for shrinkwrap plastic

Tufcoat carried out a test to compare an electric heat gun and a gas heat gun ‘side by side’ to see what are the advantages and disadvantages of each type of heat gun are when used for the shrinking of shrink wrap plastic.

 

Electric:

Electric vs gas heat gunWeighing in at 5Kg (including the cable), the electric heat gun would be tiring to use for an extended length of time It is heavier as well as more unwieldy than the propane heat gun due to the design of handle which is positioned on the top of the tool. This causes the tool to hang down from the operator’s arm, making maneuverability difficult.

Due to the slower nature of the heat gun, achieving a consistent finish on the shrink wrap is easier than with the propane tool.

The on/off switch is positioned on the rear of the tool away from the handle. It is not easy to operate using gloves (as required for welding & Health & Safety) therefore once the tool is in use it is not easy to switch off. If dropped for instance, the tool would remain on and could cause a fire before someone was able to reach it to turn it off.

The face of the tool doesn’t incorporate a heat guard and it therefore very difficult to maintain a constant distance from the shrink wrap.

The electric tool does feel safer to use and operators will probably be less apprehensive about using it initially, however the output is stated as being 650°C which is actually a higher temperature than the propane tool (which with a flame guard fitted is restricted to somewhere in the range of 340-600°C). If it isn’t actually any safer, it may even be dangerous to give the operator a feeling of safety on a ‘familiarity breeds contempt’ type argument.

The electric tool is powered by a 3-phase 415V 13A supply, and so depending on the envornment, it may be difficult to find the correct socket. In addition, long trailing 415V cables could be a trip and electric shock hazard.

 

Propane:

Electric vs gas heat gunAt only 1Kg in weight the propane tool is substantially lighter than the electric tool. It also has a pistol grip which makes it less tiring during extended use and has been designed with the shrink-wrapping of large objects in mind.

Being faster and more powerful than the electric tool, it takes more skill to achieve a consistent, tight finish. With experience though, it is possible to achieve the same finish as with the electric tool.

The on/off switch/trigger is incorporated into the pistol grip so that it is easy to operate and should the tool be dropped it automatically turns off.

The flame guard extends approx 20cm from the combustion chamber and completely encloses the flame. It must be fitted to the tool to achieve UL listing, and means that the higher output temperatures of the tool can not be used. The guard makes it easier to maintain a constant distance from the shrink wrap, however it does heat up during use and will cause holes in the film on contact.

Comments are closed.